😨 Is TikTok’s ‘Scar Girl’ Faking Her Scar for Clout?

CREATOR ECONOMY NEWSLETTER


This week for Passionfruit, writer Rebekah Harding explores the case of a TikToker known as “Scar Girl” who sparked a viral debate this month. Gaining notoriety for her viral lip-syncing videos, the TikToker, Annie Bonelli (@wtmab), garnered praise from viewers for proudly flaunting a thin scar across her cheek.

However, others voiced suspicions about whether her scar was real or just a ploy to set herself apart from the oversaturated community of lip-syncing accounts on the app. Users cited dramatic changes in the size, color, and placement of the scar, with criticisms picking up traction in January.

While “Scar Girl” denies these allegations, she seems to be cashing in on the views, comments, and responses generated from the controversy she sparked regardless. Read more about her story below.


THE DARK SIDE

‘It never fully went away, and neither did my insecurities’: People think influencer known for facial scar is faking it for clout


Become a speed demon with the fastest keyboard on the market

The next stage of keyboard evolution is here. The Razer Huntsman lineup has redefined the boundaries of precision and speed for a performance you’ve never seen before. Learn more about each Huntsman to find your weapon of choice.


ONE GREAT TIP


TIPS AND TRICKS

YouTube icon Lachlan Power shares business tips for creators

“Flexibility and speed were crucial for me in my early days.”

By Grace Stanley, Newsletter Editor


TOKWATCH

‘Why aren’t influencers honest anymore?’ Mikayla Nogueira accused of misleading viewers with false lashes in sponsored mascara TikTok

“The tendency of the beauty industry is emotionally driven consumption.”

By Charlotte Colombo, Passionfruit Contributor


IN THE BIZ


TIKTOK MADE ME DO IT

Content for Creators.

News, tips, and tricks delivered to your inbox twice a week.

Newsletter Signup

Latest Newsletters

  • Is Bernie the Next Big Manfluencer?

    Is Bernie the Next Big Manfluencer?

    CREATOR NEWSLETTER Issue #332 | April 15, 2025 – Liz Plank, Passionfruit Contributor  PERSONALITIES Twitch Streamer Literally Tortures Himself For Views The stream went on for 16 hours. By Charlotte Colombo, Passionfruit Contributor → READ THE FULL STORY SPONSORED Try Out The New TikTok Ad Assistant If you’re trying to grow your TikTok audience, buying ads that extend the reach of your content…

  • Meet the Creator Running for Congress

    Meet the Creator Running for Congress

    CREATOR NEWSLETTER Issue #331 | April 10, 2025 – Taylor Lorenz, Passionfruit Contributor  LABOR Best Buy Launches Creator Program Creators can earn uncapped commission. By Charlotte Colombo, Passionfruit Contributor → READ THE FULL STORY SPONSORED Listen to Passionfruit’s Publisher on Creator Economy Live Passionfruit’s bossman James Del sat down with Brendan Gahan and Keith Bendes from Creator Economy Live! to discuss journalism’s role in the…

  • Make Your Trolls Fight Each Other

    Make Your Trolls Fight Each Other

    CREATOR NEWSLETTER Issue #330 | April 8, 2025 This past weekend, it appeared, for a brief moment, that menswear influencer Derek Guy, aka Dieworkwear, was going to physically fight someone outside the Uniqlo Store in San Francisco. “Yesterday, someone who follows me told her husband about my tweet,” he tweeted. “He came into my replies and asked…