The Cringeification of Costumes

Issue #181 | October 31, 2023

There are swathes of creators whose whole content strategy revolves around reacting to “cringe” content. YouTube, in particular, thrives on being a bit of a freakshow. As YouTube essayist Contrapoints points out in her essay about cringe, this kind of voyeuristic content is often fueled by an “obsessive and addictive contempt” for the people whom cringe-crusaders mock.

A simple scroll through the internet will reveal some interesting internal struggles these internet Scrooges are facing as Halloween time rolls around. Some Redditors think dressing up at all on Halloween as an adult makes you stupid, saying, “Halloween adults are just as cringe as Disney adults.” Incredulous arguments abound over whether or not it’s “cringe” to cosplay on Halloween. One confused Quora user asked, “Does using a Sonic costume for Halloween make you a furry?” I don’t know, does it matter?

Halloween is an interesting time, as sexy costumes, anthropomorphism, pop culture eclecticism, and make-believe are not only tolerated but encouraged. Sexy Sonic the Hedgehog. Catwoman, Harley Quinn, Poison Ivy. Uwu cat girls and Naruto stans — these are the types of characters we’ve come to expect during the Halloween season. In fact, it becomes a bit taboo not to dress up on Halloween.

“Why is it cringe when we do cosplay but it’s not when y’all dress up as characters on Halloween?” one creator tweeted yesterday. Why indeed?

Furries, bronies, Disney adults, weebs — you name a costume-related niche, there’s an army of “cringe”-hating, snarky Redditors dedicated to making them feel bad. While cosplay has become more normalized in recent years, with some of the most popular creators on the internet proudly showing off their nerdy wares, there’s still a bit of a stigma around the practice. Patch O’Furr, the journalist behind the furry news blog Dogpatch Press, told Passionfruit “double standards” about costuming reveal underlying prejudices, and “the lack of awareness is a little ironic” at times online.

THE COMMENTS SECTION

“Judgment gets aimed at simple costuming if it may go against the assumed norms, like gender conformity… On the surface, it’s acceptable to mock silly costuming people, but the quiet part is anti-trans hate.”
—Blogger Patch O’Furr.

To his point, “cringe” haters often justify their bullying and harassment with moral condemnations. Even cosplay sometimes faces criticism of “not being safe” for kids. These kinds of moral arguments trickle down to even the most normie kinds of Halloween costumes, with women, in particular, getting slut-shamed for daring to wear a sexy costume on a night out.

Look, the internet is all about performance and spectatorship, and sometimes, it’s okay to joke about uniquely odd behavior. I too indulge in a little cringe humilitainment from time to time. (If you’re looking for some true Halloween horror today, O’Furr recommended this video about some intra-fandom discourse around disgusting costumes… look at your own risk).

But, the internet has taken cringe content too far. And with Gen Z being the least confident generation yet, fueled largely by the rise of social media algorithms that prey on our deepest insecurities, there’s certainly a fear this issue is just going to get worse.

However, paradoxically, young people tend to be more tolerant and supportive of non-mainstream interests and identities. The internet has allowed people with niche interests to find safe places to express themselves. It’s a place to build a community around the taboo, the occult, the cult classic, the freaky, the silly. The internet very much embodies the spirit of Halloween in that way.

Halloween happens to be one of my favorite holidays. I love everything witchy and ghoulish. I’m a big fan of unhinged, feral goblin and gremlin energy. Storytelling, fantasy, magic, make-believe — these things are incredibly human and beautiful. And while the internet can be a cruel and unforgiving place, you can rest assured that from me, there’s no judgment. Whether you’re rocking a bubblegum pink Barbie outfit, a cunty French bed bug costume, or a full-on werewolf fursuit today, I salute you.

– Grace Stanley, Newsletter and Features Editor

THE AUTHENTICITY DEBATE

The Latest MrBeast Debate Proves You Should Always Question What You Watch

Don’t expect your YouTubers to be genuine, especially the ones with million-dollar budgets.

By Steven Asarch, Passionfruit Contributor

→ READ THE FULL STORY

Unlock your creative potential with Skillshare

Skillshare is a learning community for creators of all levels. You can find a variety of online courses to fit your needs, whether you’re just starting your journey or looking to improve your content creation skills. Sign up today and get one month free plus 40% off.

GET STARTED

IN THE BIZ

SAG-AFTRA is facing some backlash for its strict Halloween costume policies for guild members. It took down its “strike-friendly tips and tricks” for celebrating Halloween in solidarity with the guild due to the criticisms. Notably, SNL did a parody on the topic, and actress Megan Fox sparked controversy for disobeying the recommendations.
Elon Musk announced the platform will now demonetize posts that require a community note debunking misinformation. Apt users pointed out Musk has a history of announcing “policy changes” before the official X terms of service updates, so it’s unclear if this rule is actually in effect yet.
X also appears to be doubling down on its mission to become an “everything app,” announcing it will try to rival news wire services for press releases with new products this year.
Yesterday, President Biden announced a game-changing executive order targeting AI, which pushed for more regulation of AI-collected data on social media and the adoption of disclosure marks for AI-created content.
Spotify changed its monetization policies, implementing a minimum threshold of annual streams for a track before it can earn any royalties — about 200 streams per year. Many indie songs and podcasts do not meet this threshold, so any revenue generated from their tracks will go to Spotify’s “streamshare” pool for larger artists. Bummer.

TIPS & TRICKS

How To Use Your iPhone As A Webcam

Your streaming camera might already be in your pocket.

By John-Michael Bond, Passionfruit Contributor

READ THE FULL STORY →

THE DARK SIDE

Djerf Avenue Drama Explainer: Why Creators Are Mad at the Company and What They Can Do About It

Djerf Avenue’s creator drama explained.

By Veronica Ramirez, Passionfruit Contributor

READ THE FULL STORY →

BEST HALLOWEEN COSTUME GOES TO…

Costume artist M4stiff does a mean alaskan bullworm.
Producer Tracie Morrissey killed it as queen of the gremlins.
Faucet-loving comedian Travis Stock posted this amazing cosplay of himself.
This isn’t a costume, but this skeleton is truly impressive.
And I just have to shout out the sexy French bed bugs one more time.

HALLOWEEN MADE ME DO IT

We spoke with songwriting comedy legend Nick Lutsko, aka the Gremlin King of Spirit Halloween, about his roots in Chattanooga, TN, and his path toward becoming a creator in a small town. Check out the interview below.